Annex 1: Ministerial Letter to largest 50 pension schemes
Updated 7 July 2021
Clarifying and strengthening trustees investment duties on ESG and climate risk
I am writing to you to remind you of the amendments to the Investment and Disclosure regulations which come into force on 1 October 2019. With this package, I have sought to put beyond doubt:
- the duties for pension scheme trustees to take account of financially material considerations arising from environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations, including climate change � just as they would any other financial risk
- the requirement to have a policy on stewardship of the assets, including both engagement and voting, however the assets are held
- the requirement to have a policy on how members� views are taken into account, although I have been clear that trustees are never obliged to take account of members� views
I believe that the circumstances in which neither climate risks, nor ESG risks more broadly, are financially material are likely to be extremely limited � and therefore that it is part and parcel of trustees� fiduciary duties to take account of these risks when setting out investment strategy and to clearly explain that to investors. In the same way, I believe it is part of trustees� fiduciary duties to have a stewardship policy, even if that policy is limited to engagement and monitoring of the asset managers who engage with investee firms and vote on trustees� behalf. Finally, the Law Commission have twice concluded that trustees can take account of members� views where the “two step test� is met.
In light of the coming into force of the Regulations, and Government and Parliamentary interest in pension scheme investment, I am writing to ask some further questions about the actions undertaken by your scheme.
Question 1:
What substantive changes have you made to your investment strategy in the last 3 years to take account of ESG and climate change and when have you made them?
Question 2:
What substantive changes have you made to your stewardship policy in the last 3 years to ensure that the pension scheme trustees act as engaged investors?
Question 3:
Have you made any substantive changes to your policy on taking account of members� views in the last 3 years? If so, what changes have you made and when did you make them?
Question 4:
Are you planning to make any further changes to your strategies and policies on the above topics in the next 12 months?
Question 5:
Does your scheme make climate disclosures in line with the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) framework? What aspects of TCFD’s recommendations do you meet? Do you plan to meet more in the next 12 months?
Question 6:
Are there further specific actions government might take to impress upon pension schemes � or others � the materiality of climate change risk and how it might be minimised. If so, what are those actions?
Question 7:
Who are your asset manager/s and do you believe they are truly acting on the changes I and government are seeking?
Question 8:
Finally, I would appreciate sight of the ESG/climate change, stewardship and non-financial factors (members� views) section of your statement of investment principles, or details of where these are published online. I am compiling a record so I can both monitor compliance and celebrate and support best practice.
Guy Opperman MP
Minister for Pensions and Financial Inclusion